Bishops in Alberta Have Serious Questions Regarding the Ethics of Nuclear Energy
Written by Glenn Pearston   
Thursday, 18 June 2009 12:28
Archbishop Richard Smith Catholic bishops in Alberta say that serious questions of an ethical nature need answering before decisions should be made regarding whether to build reactors for nuclear power in the area. In a letter delivered Wednesday, the ACCB (Alberta Conference of Catholic Bishops) requested more input from the public regarding the question of nuclear power, expressing concerns regarding safekeeping of the environment, the effect on supplies of water, protection of humanity, security concerns and sufficient consultation. Catholic Bishop Henry said that expert opinions regarding nuclear energy remain divided, the debate could likely become polarized. An online survey conducted by the energy department wasn't sufficient considering the issues size and the possible impact it may have on generations to come and the environment, Henry said.

Because of the amount of problems there have been regarding nuclear energy, we need to hold a public hearing, have a thoughtful discussion regarding this. It's time serious questions were raised.

Bruce Power, of Ontario, proposed construction of a $6.2 billion power plant in Peace River of northwestern Alberta.

Bob McManus, who is an Alberta Energy spokesman, stated that the government used several methods meant to garner pubic opinion regarding the contentious matter.

Forums were conducted in several places around Alberta and we heard ordinary citizens opinions, we completed an online survey and there has been many letters and many phone calls, said McManus. We believe that it has been an extensive public inclusion process and are awaiting results of those measures.

Bishops of Alberta hope to compile a study guide by fall that will assist Catholic parishes or other interested parties educate themselves regarding nuclear power issues.

Henry said, regarding the church's endeavor in gathering input, I'm not certain that we want to take a lead in the public discussions, but certainly we'd like to be players.

He said that a role is raising the moral and the ethical issues which need consideration.

In the letter, bishops stated, A sustained consultation where stakeholders could speak face-to-face with decision makers in the government is needed. The letter said that it needed to be a public and transparent process. The letter also stressed that voices of residents in the area of the proposed sites of the nuclear plants, mainly Metis communities and Aboriginal communities, need to be heard.

Archbishop Richard Smith said that a lot of discussion up to now has been focusing on the technological, financial and scientific issues.

Smith said that these are important, but that they'd like to make the suggestion that other ethical matters be included in the discussion. Now that there is a possibility of projects coming before the province, we should weigh all the risks, all benefits and be certain people of the province are informed.

Dlena Schacherl from the NFAC (Nuclear Free Alberta Coalition) supported the bishops' position.

There are several options for power production in Alberta, the important thing is more people need to get educated regarding this matter. People have to consider the type of future their children should have and they're grandchildren, Schacher said.


Glenn Pearston
Written on Thursday, 18 June 2009 12:28 by Glenn Pearston

Viewed 1256 times so far. Like this? Tweet it to your followers!

Rate this article

Latest articles from Glenn Pearston

Latest 'tweets' from Safe Nuclear Energy

  • RT @NuclearAnalyst U.S. Companies Buying Enriched Uranium From Russia - Nuclear Safety http://cli.gs/mvN3ut (via @tweetmeme) Link Friday, 19 June 2009 17:27
  • RT @NuclearAnalyst OakFlat DOS Nuclear Reactor Simulator Game - Nuclear Safety http://cli.gs/GhHAnv (via @tweetmeme) Link Friday, 19 June 2009 16:06
  • RT @NuclearAnalyst Senate Energy Committee Approves Energy Bill - Nuclear Safety http://tinyurl.com/nb22s8 (via @tweetmeme) Link Friday, 19 June 2009 12:18
  • RT @NuclearAnalyst Women Play a Key Role in Energy Future - Nuclear Safety http://cli.gs/DaGWHP (via @tweetmeme) Link Friday, 19 June 2009 11:53
  • RT @NuclearAnalyst Elmore County Idaho Wants Nuclear Plant on Snake River - Nuclear Safety http://tinyurl.com/kwksx6 (via @tweetmeme) Link Friday, 19 June 2009 10:05

 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Official Resources

site-nrc
The US Nuclear Regulator Commission website has a wealth of information on the plants, safety protocols, and more. Link
site-iaea
The International Atomic Energy Agency is the primariy international nuclear authority focussing on nuclear verification and security, safety and technology transfer. Link
site-nnsa
The National Nuclear Security Administration deals with military use of nuclear power and nuclear weapons safety and proliferation. Link